The video presented by Mufti Imran Bashir discusses the controversial topic of whether there are errors in the Quran. The video aims to challenge the audience's beliefs regarding the infallibility of the Quran, inviting viewers to question their understanding of Islamic teachings.
Personal Belief and Religion Choice
Skepticism Towards Other Religions
The Nature of Faith
Questioning the Compilation of the Quran
Hadith and Historical Context
“If you deny even one letter, one word, one point, will you still have faith? No.”
“How can a goat eat the verses of Allah?”
“This means that Allah Himself has taken the responsibility of preserving this Quran.”
Mufti Imran Bashir's video serves as a provocative exploration of faith, belief, and the integrity of religious texts. By questioning the infallibility of the Quran, the video challenges viewers to reflect deeply on their beliefs and encourages a more nuanced understanding of faith in the context of historical and textual analysis.
সাধারণত মুমিনদের জনপ্রিয় এক দাবি হলো, কুরআনের একটা আয়াতেও ভুল নেই। আসলেই কি? ভুল না থাকা আর ভুল অস্বীকার করা ভিন্ন ব্যাপার। এই ভিডিওটি আপনার চোখে আঙ্গুল দিয়ে দেখিয়ে দেবে কুরআনের আয়াত ভুল প্রমাণিত হয়েছে, নাকি হয়নি! দেখুন, ভাবুন। আমার সাথে সরাসরি যোগাযোগ করতে চাইলে এই লিংকে https://www.patreon.com/14890729/join গিয়ে মেসেজ করুন। চাইলে আমাদের এই অগ্রযাত্রায় আর্থিকভাবে অংশগ্রহণ করতে পারেন যে কোন একটি মেম্বারশিপ কিনে। হাফেজ এনামের ফেসবুক আইডি : https://www.facebook.com/share/1ZyJSTUqDh/ মুফতি ইমরান বশিরের ফেসবুক আইডি: https://www.facebook.com/share/1DManVqBBR/ নবী কেন পুত্র*ব*ধুকে বিয়ে করলেন?👇 https://youtu.be/SA4QJmxywN0?si=lLDXz2OTMTM5dtlG শবে মেরাজের চেপে রাখা ইতিহাস👇 https://youtu.be/wQQ_6nvXf2E?si=_Acmr6eK7cj2MMAc তাকদীর নিয়ে ভিডিও : https://youtu.be/1h4-ct_mx5M?si=14wSLX1euZHc-eDq মুফতি ইমরান বসিরের ফেসবুক পেজ 👇 কথা বলো ফেসবুক পেজ : https://www.facebook.com/kothaboloimran Mufti Imran Bin Bashir ফেসবুক পেজ : https://www.facebook.com/HM.ImranBashir/ HM Imran Bashir ইউটিউব চ্যানেল 👇 https://youtube.com/@BibiMoriam24?si=xBtNrbwLhF318f9g হাফেজ এনামের ইউটিউব চ্যানেল 👇 https://www.youtube.com/@AnamulHoque%E0%A6%8F%E0%A6%A8%E0%A6%BE%E0%A6%AE যোগাযোগ করতে ইমেইল করুন 👇 imranbashir1997@gmail.com kothabolo71@gmail.com #কুরআন #ইসলাম #কুরআনে_ভুল #Quran #QuranMistakes #QuranAnalysis #QuranCriticism #Islam #IslamQuestions #IslamDebate #QuranResearch #IslamicDiscussion #CollegeStudentInterview #BanglaContent #মুক্তচিন্তা #imran_bashir #mufti_imran
You are a Muslim, right? Yes, there are thousands of religions in the world. Why are you Muslim? Why did you choose to accept Islam over all other religions? Because Islam seems true to me. I believe in it with all my heart. I believe in it with all my heart and it seems true. Why does it seem true? Because when I was young, I studied in various Islamic schools, I received the education from the teachers. Then, what I saw in my family, what I was taught from my childhood, what I saw, what I learned, I slowly nurtured it within myself. Similarly, if a Hindu is born in a Hindu family, then they receive their education in religious places of worship or through religious education, they also consider their religion to be true . Do you think that if you accept Islam, according to Islam, are the other religions true or false? Other religions seem false to me. They seem false. Have you studied other religions? No. Have you studied your religion? Islam? Yes, roughly. Okay. The basic beliefs of Islam are that we believe in the afterlife. There is heaven, there is hell. There is Allah, Gabriel, Michael, right? There are many great angels that we have been hearing about all the time. Yes, well, have you seen heaven or hell, neither Allah nor Gabriel, nor anyone? We have heard these words from a person, he is Muhammad (peace be upon him) He is a human being. Can it be that he deceived us, lied? No, it can be. Why can't it be? Have you studied his biography? Yes, I have read it quite a bit. I have heard it again. Well, the Quran is a book that Allah revealed to the Prophet. This is what Allah revealed. Do you have any proof for this? I don't have it. Well, who do you think has it? Why do you believe that the Quran is the word of Allah? Because it teaches us from childhood, that means that what we have learned from childhood is what we have accepted without doing anything, that means only faith here, have you ever searched for the rationality behind faith, have you ever searched for it as an adult? I always ask myself one thing now that like Hinduism, there are various idols, but they make them themselves and say that they are their creator. They don't think that they are their creator, they think that since they have not seen this creator, they make a portrait of him and respect him . Through this, they mean God, they worship the original God. Which is also our religion. It is a bit like worship. For example, the Black Stone is nothing more than a stone. When we kiss it, our sins are forgiven. What do you call this? How does a stone have power and surround that stone and the Kaaba Sharif which is also a building is okay a small house we go around that house thinking it is the house of Allah and go to do tawaf millions of people are going from the whole world are going to Saudi Arabia the thing has become the same it seemed to you it was the same well I am not going to believe that then I am asking you then regarding the compilation of the Quran the word of Allah that the Quran has told you this you have no proof right just believe and hear well well well I am saying things according to what we have heard since childhood or what the scholars have narrated to us . Is a verse of the Quran okay? If you deny even a letter, a word or a point, will you have faith? No. In this case you agree right? We have heard this since childhood and all the scholars here say this. Well, that which was revealed from Allah to Muhammad (peace be upon him) is that, but the Quran is right. Well, I will tell you a hadith. Surah Ahzab is a Surah of the Quran. There are 73 verses in this Surah in the current Quran. This is my Tafsir by Ibn Kathir. Allama Ibn Kathir, Islamic Foundation, Volume 9, Page 19. You will find it here. It is narrated from Rahmatullahi Alaihi Alaihi that Uba ibn Ka'b (may Allah be pleased with him) once asked me how many verses there are in Surah Ahzab. I said, 73. He said, "Be quiet. It is the equivalent of Surah Al-Baqarah. We recited in it, " Allah is the Judge . When an old woman commits adultery, strike her with a broad sword and kill her. This is a punishment from Allah. Allah is the Mighty, the Wise. Do you understand a little bit? There are 73 verses in Surah Ahzab in the current Quran. But he says that during the time of the Messenger of Allah, we used to read the verses of this Surah Ahzab. We used to think of this Surah as Surah Baqarah. Surah Baqarah is the largest Surah of the Quran. Okay, if I tell you, the number of verses of Surah Baqarah is 286. It may be a little like this. I haven't seen it. I mean, the largest Surah, you see. 200. It came down from 86 to 73. Where are the remaining verses? Naturally, the question doesn't arise? Hmm. Where are the remaining verses? If the matter is that the remaining verses have been lost. They could not be preserved. Do you know? During the time of Muhammad (peace be upon him), the Quran could not be compiled. This was done by Abu Bakr. Then Omar. Then during the reign of the third Caliph, Hazrat Osman (may Allah be pleased with him), this Quran was compiled. Before that, during the time of the Messenger of Allah, during the time of Abu Bakr, during the time of Omar, the Quran was not compiled. It was scattered and carved on stones. Some were on the leaves of trees. They were written in various places. In that case, many companions fought. There were many reciters. They had them memorized. They had them in their minds, in their hearts. So, as soon as they died, those verses were lost. There is also a hadith like this. Then there is a hadith narrated by Allah Aisha (may Allah be pleased with her) that this verse related to resin was revealed. The verse related to resin was written on a sheet under my bed. When the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) passed away, we were all busy, and a goat came and ate it . Well, these verses of the Quran were lost or the verses revealed by Allah were eaten by goats. The goat ate them. This verse is of course preserved, but it is not in the current Quran. What do you think after hearing all this? There is a place in the Quran where I revealed this Quran and I am responsible for its preservation. That means Allah Himself has taken the responsibility of preserving this Quran. If he has taken the responsibility to preserve this Quran, then the verses of the Quran are not one or two. How can hundreds of verses be lost? How can the verses of the Quran be eaten by goats? Do these things create any doubt in your mind? Why not? How can a goat eat the verses of Allah? A goat moves or eats only by the command of Allah, right? We know this. Nothing happens without the command of Allah. So the verses of Allah that he has taken the responsibility to preserve. It is in the Quran. So is this verse of the Quran not proven wrong? No, how is it not proven? Then where did the rest of the verses go? He said that Surah Ahzab was equivalent to Surah Baqarah. But the current Quran has only 73 verses. Another 100 or about 200 verses have been lost. Where did these go? I mean, my question to you is that atheists are throwing questions at us. We are not really able to answer these questions. I can't say I can give it my research, maybe I can give it some time. But I still can't find the answers. I will go to the scholars. The scholars actually keep quiet like this. I may go to the bigger scholars. Mizanur Rahman Azhari says or Dr. Zakir Naik says I will bring them in front of my camera in the same way. But it is not very easy to bring them. So you say you are an educated person. Okay ? You have a conscience, emotions and since you are a Muslim and hold Islam in your heart, I can also ask you this question. Have you ever heard these words? No, I haven't. Now that you have heard it, I don't believe my words, but I have references. Well, when you believe it, now you answer . According to your IQ and the intelligence you have, what will you answer ? You have the answer. Do you believe that all these things question the verse of the Quran that Allah has taken the responsibility of preserving the Quran, that verse of the Quran was lost. We could not find out about it. The verses of the Quran were eaten by goats. We didn't know about it. Or we found out that it's not in the current Quran. Is that questionable? Yes. Okay, okay.







