LA INVASIÓN DEL PLÁSTICO COCA COLA Y UN MUNDO LLENO DE BASURA.
Description
LA INVASIÓN DEL PLÁSTICO COCA COLA Y UN MUNDO LLENO DE BASURA.
Details
- Published
- Feb 24, 2020
- Views
- 3,815
- Duration
- 40:27
LA INVASIÓN DEL PLÁSTICO COCA COLA Y UN MUNDO LLENO DE BASURA.
Environmental Impact of Plastic Waste
Coca-Cola's Role in Plastic Production
Corporate Promises and Accountability
Tanzania
Expert Testimony
"Coca-Cola behaves in a way... that shifts the responsibility onto the consumer."
"We produce so many complex synthetic materials that it's impossible to separate them all and recycle them; it simply can't be done."
The documentary serves as a powerful indictment of Coca-Cola’s environmental practices while emphasizing the broader implications of plastic waste in our society. It calls for accountability from corporations and advocates for a more sustainable approach to packaging and consumer habits. The exploration of these themes is crucial in the ongoing dialogue about environmental responsibility and corporate ethics.
Hawaii, in the middle of the Pacific Ocean. No matter how remote these islands are, even on their shores there are large quantities of plastic waste. It decomposes extremely slowly and the mountains continue to grow. Scientists from the University of Hawaii are studying the Pacific and its inhabitants and are finding more and more plastic. I have no idea what this is, but it is definitely plastic. Jessica Perelman is a biologist. She started collecting the plastic waste she finds in the stomachs of fish. Sometimes we find plastic bags. I found this one completely crumpled up in a stomach and then I spread it out. How do you react to a discovery like this? I was shocked. Then I started documenting, measuring and photographing everything and showing it to my colleagues. We were shocked to see that the fish ingest so much garbage. To her surprise, the biologist even found plastic waste in sand eels. Something the researcher thought was impossible for this species. Plastic of all kinds. Sometimes you even find labels like the ones on this bottle of Dasani. What is that? A label from a bottle of Dasani brand water found in the stomach of a sand eel. It’s a well-known brand. Yes, Dasani is a very popular brand of table water. When we find labels like this, we can determine where the trash originally came from. Indeed, Dasani is one of the most widely marketed brands of table water in the world. And even someone who has never heard the name before will probably be familiar with the parent company Coca-Cola. Less well-known is the fact that dozens of other brands also belong to the Coca-Cola group of companies, such as Dasani, Apolinaris, Sprite, Capio Minute Made, Powerid and, of course, Fanta, another of its best-known brands. The company sells over 120 billion bottles worldwide annually, which equates to almost 4,000 bottles per second and, therefore, an immense amount of trash. In January 2018, the group promised its customers a world without waste by 2030. CEO James Quincy announced the ambitious plan in person. We need to build a circular economy with its own value creation. It’s doable. A world without waste, where synthetic materials are recycled almost indefinitely. Is it possible? And how seriously does the Coca-Cola Group take its promise? First, we wanted to know more about how Coca-Cola has been handling the problem of plastic waste so far. To find out, we traveled to the country where Coca-Cola was born, the United States. Here in rural Virginia lives an expert strategist for the beverage group. Hello, everyone. Hello, Bart. Nice to meet you. Nice to meet you. I’m Sandrin. Welcome to Virginia. Thank you. It’s hard to reach him. Yes, I know. Come in, please. Thank you. Let’s go. Bart Elmore is a historian specializing in environmental issues. His book, Citizen Coke, about the group's thoughtless politics was a bestseller in the United States. It also addresses the mountains of trash that have been growing steadily since the 1960s. Since then, we've seen the garbage piling up in heaps. Coca-Cola has tried to respond to this situation. Oh, they're holding us responsible for this amount of aluminum and plastic trash. What does that mean? Keep America Beautiful. You think of a group of bearded environmentalists. Or at least that's what I thought. You see their logo everywhere in America. It's still very much alive. The amazing thing is that it was founded by beverage companies, bottlers and packaging companies. Their idea was, let's make consumers feel guilty. After all, they're the ones who produce the trash. The industry gets clean hands. An Indian who looks like Carl Ma makes the Keep America Beautiful commercials famous in the United States. And this guy throws trash at their feet from his car. Then we get a close-up of the Indian man with his face streaming with tears, and a newscaster comes on and says, "People started the pollution. People can stop it." The message is clear. 1970s commercial. Kip America Beautiful has continued to grow. Today, there are virtually identical organizations all over the world, and they all receive support from Coca-Cola. The soft drink manufacturer still follows the principle of blaming others. We see this in Versailles, where, exceptionally, we are not going to visit the palace, but to attend a conference at the City Hall. The conference focuses on keeping cities clean, and its speakers are high-profile figures, including representatives of municipal associations from all over Europe. The final speaker and guest of honor is Derek Robertson, director of Keep Scotland Beautiful, the Scottish branch of Keep America Beautiful, clearly a supporter of carbonated drinks. Your message is almost indistinguishable from that of the Indian man in tears. I am lucky to be working for an organization in Scotland, in a part of Scotland that Europe doesn't give a damn about. I was going to that is to say, that he doesn't care about his own responsibility. Again, the call for individual responsibility and not that of the group. Does he not consider it a problem? I saw them drinking Coca-Cola. Aren't disposable plastic bottles also a problem? We can't forget that plastic packaging has a very useful social function. The products are very creative, very useful and fulfill an important function. The important thing is that everyone should take care of recycling the packaging. Coca-Cola wants to recover them, recycle them and reuse them. The idea is that they do not pollute the environment. In other words, Coca-Cola is behaving in an exemplary manner, says the head of a supposed environmental protection organization. Does he think his association is financed with funds from the soft drinks consortium? We'll ask after the conference. I'm asking a legitimate journalistic question. Yeah. I work full time for my organization in Scotland. I'm fully committed to this mission. I work for Don Norem, understand? I work for the Scottish Government and for local councils who pay us for What we do. Also for companies. Yes, also for companies. Which ones? How long has it been around? There are many. Coca-Cola, HM, McDonald's, Wiggles, Starbucks. All big brand names . All big companies and all have learned from Coca-Cola how to avoid scandal. But what if Coca-Cola really wanted to change something? When the group spoke out in favor of a world without waste in 2018, it announced a series of ambitious measures to solve the problem of plastic waste. For Coca-Cola, recycling is the right option, that is, collecting used bottles to make new bottles. Coca-Cola promised to make 50%of its bottles from recycled material by 2030 worldwide. It is absolutely feasible. There are models for China and other parts of the world that show how to give value to plastic and reuse it. It seems like a good project, however, it would be useful to know to what extent the Coca-Cola group keeps its promises, since this is not the first time it has announced its intention to use recycled plastic. Yes. did so in 2008. Back then , in its Sustainable Development Report , Coca-Cola set itself a target: All of its bottles would contain 25%recycled plastic by 2015. We tried to find these figures in the 2015 report, unfortunately in vain. Nowhere does it say that the group has fulfilled its promise. Finally, we found a figure: 12.4%. You could say that there is a percentage of recycled plastic in Coca-Cola bottles. But when you look closely at these figures, 12.4%turns out to be the total of recycled materials used plus renewable raw materials. In other words, these are two different sources of materials. To find out exactly what this means, we met with an environmental activist who has been analyzing the carbonated drinks group's policy for a long time. Elen Burge is a specialist in maritime protection. She knows how to read between the lines of Coca-Cola's statistics. Coca-Cola's plastic material is described as renewable. It is obtained from plants, mainly corn starch. They call their bottles eco-friendly and give them a small inscription. But the raw material used does not change the environmental impact at all. Even though eco-friendly plastic bottles are made from plants, chemically they are exactly the same as PET bottles made from petroleum and generate the same amount of waste. Isn't this 12.4% recycled material? No, it is not. We even have an email from Coca-Cola stating that it currently only uses 7% recycled plastic material, despite its goal for 2015 being 25%. The figures are far from the target set. Environmentalists believe that Coca-Cola's recycling promises are for advertising purposes to keep consumers buying plastic bottles. When companies use huge amounts of plastic, they sell the idea that recycling is the solution to the problem, but it is not that simple. We currently produce so many synthetic and complex materials that it is impossible to separate them all and recycle them. It simply cannot be done. So Coca-Cola tweaks its environmental statistics. And that's not all. Inside this envelope is a folder with internal letters from Coca-Cola’s lobbying group for the European Union in Brussels. All of these items describe planned EU measures that are not in Coca-Cola’s interests, such as carbon emissions trading, restrictions on caffeine intake, and a ban on advertising to children under 12. All of these could have some impact on Coca-Cola’s sales. The word “fight back” is written in a circle. These are the EU’s goals that Coca-Cola is trying to prevent with its lobbying efforts. Among the measures that Coca-Cola flatly rejects are stricter collection and recycling targets. And among the categories that need to be fought is the deposit-return system, which works perfectly in many European countries. This system prevents packaging from ending up in the environment, but Coca-Cola is opposed to it. The absurdity of all this is that Coca-Cola itself originally supported returnable bottles with good results. In the 1950s, the cult American drink was sold only in bottles . glass bottles, for which the customer paid a kind of deposit. The empty bottles were returned to the factory where they were washed and refilled, a system that practically did not pollute the environment, it worked perfectly. However, Coca-Cola later decided to introduce plastic bottles against the express advice of experts. Almost no one knows the story of the end of the returnable bottle of American Coca-Cola . The corporation kept it hidden for a long time. However, there is one man who still remembers it perfectly. Today he is retired and lives modestly in the US state of Michigan. Hello, I'm Sandrin Rigo. Nice to meet you. Thank you for having us. Please come in . Thank you. Thank you very much. Arsenney was an engineer and worked for many years in the service of the US environmental authority. In that capacity he was the first, a typical Coca-Cola bottle. It was this big, green, transparent and always made of glass. That's how Darney remembers the Coca-Cola bottle from the early 1970s. It was just starting to arouse interest, considering the impact on the environment and nature. For a whole year, this engineer spent his research and compared the environmental pollution of glass bottles with that of aluminum cans and plastic bottles. Upon completing his analysis and complex calculations, he came to an unequivocal conclusion. The table shows that returnable glass bottles, after being refilled at least 15 times, are clearly the most environmentally friendly container. Thanks to this report, Coca-Cola knew in the early 1970s that returnable glass bottles pollute the environment much less than plastic ones. However, the company keeps this information to itself. We prepared it for them and they did not publish it. And why would it not direct their future? I had to watch them introduce the plastic bottle . In 1975, Coca-Cola began advertising its new plastic bottles and shelved the study prepared by Arsen Darney. The decision was made. Coca-Cola introduced plastic bottles worldwide and other corporate groups followed suit. Plastic began to leave the factories. Already in the 1970s, Coca-Cola began to produce plastic bottles. In 1980, the growing problem of littering caused environmentalists to react. Some American states wanted to make returnable bottles mandatory, but they were not yet aware of the power of the Coca-Cola Group. Coca-Cola is always at the forefront of all legal measures that would impose a returnable bottle system or a tax on packaging waste. Its newsletters regularly celebrate the success of this battle. Why do you think the corporation is acting so forcefully against a returnable bottle system? What is the reason? Placing a deposit on bottles would cost them more money and would force them to include disposal costs. After all, it is a clever market mechanism that forces the industry to solve its own litter problem. In the meantime, the Coca-Cola Group publicly promises a world without litter. That is our goal, and its lobbyists have been secretly working for 40 years to prevent environmentally friendly alternatives to plastic bottles. Okay, ready, action. We have many questions for Coca-Cola. After months of negotiations, the corporate group has granted us a Interview at your French headquarters. Michael Goldsman has come all the way from the United States specifically to answer our questions in Paris. Good morning. This executive has worked for Coca-Cola since 1997, where he heads the global strategies and sustainability division. What is the percentage of plastic? What is the percentage of recycled plastic that Coca-Cola uses worldwide in its bottles? Recycled plastic by 2015. We are now in 2018 and the goal is far from being met. You yourselves say that it is barely 7%because you were unable to reach the target because it was very difficult. You are right. We have not reached our goals. We are aware of this. We have to improve, but with our strategy we believe we can achieve it. But we agree that you are very far from the goal. Yes, I agree with you. However, we have had this strategy since January and it is now July. In other words, Coca-Cola has been working with a real strategy since January 2018. They have been working for more than 6 months now. We participate in collection and recycling systems in many countries. In France, we have already made investments in 2012, so it's nothing new, but the strategy dates back to January 2018. Are you familiar with this document? Yes. However, it does not reflect our current strategy. It comes from Coca-Cola. You know, it's only a few years old. It's from 2016. That is, it's only two years old. In January, we announced our new strategy and this document is not in line with our current strategy or our corporate policy. And Sofia Crisopolu is still part of the lobbying group in Brussels. That means she modified this graph. It's different now. Yes, it's different. Can you give us the new graph? No, I don't have a graph to give me. It hasn't changed much in two years. In 2016, you were fighting this measure and now you're defending it. How can that be? We are in constant contact with third parties. We communicate our guidelines and analyze them regularly. We have decided that the goal now is to invest seriously. So, on the one hand, they say they really want to make changes, but on the other hand, this strategic document appears that must be kept up to date. confidentiality. We have to make a value judgment. We will take another trip. Tanzania. This East African country boasts of its dreamlike landscapes, its pristine beaches and its exciting photographic adventures. What is not shown in the advertisement is that Tanzania is the quintessential Coca-Cola country. At bus stops, on the walls of houses or in playgrounds, the red and white logo is so present everywhere that one is barely aware of it. In any case, returnable glass Coca-Cola bottles are still found in Tanzania. This could be good news if it were still the case. Hey, however, the American consortium is doing in Tanzania what it started in the United States almost 50 years ago. Glass is being eliminated; everything is new here. We are proudly accompanied by James Malaba, head of this production line where only plastic bottles come off the belt. Today, Fanta is bottled, which like many other carbonated beverage brands belongs to the Coca-Cola group. Tons of bottles. The employees here They just feed the laborious machines. And this is the pineapple Fanta counter. How many has he bottled so far? It's 86,340 bottles. That's the production of 2 and a half hours. 86,340 bottles in 2 and a half hours, or 10 bottles per second. And only 5 years ago here they only bottled in glass containers. But now the glass bottle conveyor belt has practically stopped. People want to take everything . The thing is that returnable bottles have to be returned and also PET bottles are very aesthetic and beautiful. He believes that the use of plastic has more to do with appearance than with money. For glass bottles, people have to take care of returning them. But I don't want bottles returned to me, I just want to sell. From Malaba's point of view, plastic is not a problem for the environment in Tanzania. It's good business. Everyone wants to do business. That's why people collect plastic. 80%of the Plastic is recycled. After the visit, we want to learn more about this efficient way of doing things. The truth is that the country is drowning in garbage and the supposedly good business with empty Coca-Cola bottles is as pitiful as it is dirty. A task that only the poorest do. How it kills. She raises her three children alone. In order to buy them something to eat, she collects plastic on the beach. What type of plastic is best? The bottles in greatest demand are hard plastic. It's always good to find some, but I grab all kinds of bottles. Coca-Cola. So far, I haven't found much. Here in Tanzania, we met an old acquaintance, Tasani table water. In an 8-hour day, Ma collects up to 20 kg of plastic. They pay her 250 shillings per kilo. In euros, that's 8 cents. In other words, her daily wage doesn't even come close to € 2 if the day is productive. Why do I do this? It's good for earning some money. Don't think that one can live on this, but I have to do it. The last few months have been difficult because prices are at rock bottom. Why? What did they dump? Why is there so much plastic? Too much plastic ruins prices and there are too many poor collectors like Mata who have no other income. Go to the country’s largest garbage dump, in Dare Salam, Tanzania’s economic hub. Everyone jumps on the truck as soon as they see it coming. Plastic bags, plastic bottles like this one. These are the best bottles, clean, clear and made of rigid plastic. They’re good, but you have to spend a lot of time looking for them because they’re hard to find in this system. They set the prices and when even one of us says yes, the others have to resign themselves. It’s time to clean the camera lens and look beyond. Who are the ones dictating ridiculous prices to the collectors and condemning them to a life of bitter poverty? One of the buyers is based in a suburb of Dare Salam. He is the country’s main middleman for dealing in used plastic. On the company’s vast premises, the view is surreal. A gigantic mountain of empty bottles. Each worker here carries up to 70 kg of plastic. Human ants that go up and down with a load greater than themselves. How do they cope? The biggest problem here is the sun. The sun is merciless. Everything is from an unimaginable society and we collect here with bare hands. Recycling companies. Until recently, this material was exported to China, the world's largest market for used plastic. But that's over, as the manager explains. Yesterday I heard a collector say that prices have been at rock bottom for a few months. Why? Because China, Vietnam and Malaysia, but most of the plastic waste continues to accumulate, burn or end up in the sea. We're interested in knowing what Michael Goldsman has to say about this. He's the director of Coca-Cola's Environmental Policy Division. I would be happy to show him some footage from our most recent shoots. Six years ago, Coca-Cola didn't sell a single plastic bottle. They were all returnable glass bottles. But today, Coca-Cola sells plastic bottles in bulk . It also packages in plastic bottles. Why was this decision made? It depends on the consumer. All types of packaging have pros and cons. Consumers want to be able to carry their drinks in lighter containers. In other words, we have to ensure that these bottles are collected, and we want to do that. You switched production to plastic six years ago because you didn't set up a collection system there. The important thing is that we're doing it now. I don't think it's important that nothing has happened for six years. You introduced plastic bottles without taking care of collection and recycling . Today we have a new strategy. We want to establish a circular economy. By circular economy, you basically mean the same thing as the recycling economy . I ask you to listen to a testimony. She describes what this branch of the economy is like in Tanzania today. Look , I do this to earn some money. Don't think that you can live on this. What do you think? Our bottles can't be worth more. All used PET bottles have a value. Don't you think Coca-Cola made a mistake in Tanzania? I don't like seeing these kinds of images. Nobody likes it. It's clear to me that there are objections to synthetic materials and we respond with the poor system. We haven't started the project yet, but we have plans. Do you mean they haven't invested anything yet ? We haven't invested anything yet. We want to implement the same model in Tanzania to promote PET recycling as in South Africa and in a year we should be able to see it up and running. Coca-Cola promises a world without waste. In the words of its CEO James Quincy, do you think a world without plastic is really possible? Our vision is not a world without plastic. We see the advantages that plastic offers, for example, its low weight. But we also see disadvantages, so we want to put certain systems in place to be able to keep it under control. This is what the future looks like for Coca-Cola. Even more plastic bottles. The consortium is further than ever from its promises of a world without waste with a circular economy. And during the time this documentary was made, Coca-Cola sold more than 10 million bottles.







